The Storyline

"Real families.Real discoveries.Real stories."

Scattered Stones: The Orphan’s Journey

Scattered Stones: The Orphan’s Journey

Scattered Stones: Episode 8

In January 1924, eighteen-year-old Lillian Robertson lost both parents within twelve days. Her father Joseph died of a cerebral hemorrhage; her mother Mary Agnes followed him, claimed by tuberculosis. The orphaned daughter of a stone cutter's son and a mat maker's daughter faced an uncertain future.

But Lillian didn't just survive—she built. She married a Brooklyn carpenter, returned to the New Jersey town where she was orphaned, and raised six children. She lost her only sister to tuberculosis in 1942, and her daughter Helen Grace at age eight in 1948. Yet by 1978, she celebrated her golden anniversary surrounded by seventeen of her nineteen grandchildren.

This is the story of resilience across six generations—from a Scottish stone cutter in Blairgowrie to a grandmother in Caldwell, New Jersey.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones: The Son Who Searched
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Scattered Stones: The Son Who Searched

Scattered Stones: Episode 7

In February 1910, Joseph Robertson traveled to Georgia searching for his missing father—the stone cutter who had vanished into the swamps. He never found answers. Fourteen years later, Joseph died of the same stroke that killed his mother. Twelve days after that, his wife Mary Agnes—daughter of Brooklyn's mat maker John Kenny—followed him to the grave. Their three children were orphaned within two weeks. This is where two Brooklyn families meet, and where my grandmother's story begins.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series : Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones: The Stone Cutter’s Journey
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Scattered Stones: The Stone Cutter’s Journey

Scattered Stones: Episode 6

Of all the children of George Robertson and Margaret Paterson, David was the pioneer—the first to cross the Atlantic, the first to establish the family name in America. For forty years he built a life in Brooklyn, cutting stone, raising eleven children. Then, at sixty-three, newly widowed, he reinvented himself as a game trapper in Georgia. In February 1910, he vanished. His boat was found swamped. His body was never recovered. This is the story of David Paterson Robertson—and the son who traveled from Brooklyn to Georgia searching for answers that never came.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series : Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones : Scattered Fates
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Scattered Stones : Scattered Fates

Scattered Stones: Episode 5

They scattered like seeds in the wind — some taking root in Brooklyn's granite, others drifting to Liverpool's docks, still others clinging to the Scottish soil where they were born. John married in Dundee; his grandson's gravestone still stands in Rattray. Margaret worked as a tablemaid in Blairgowrie. James became a gamekeeper in Liverpool after passing through Canada. And Mary Ann — the firstborn — wandered from Nova Scotia to Saskatchewan before dying in New Jersey in 1921, the last survivor of all ten children.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones: The Brooklyn Robertsons
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Scattered Stones: The Brooklyn Robertsons

Scattered Stones: Episode 4

Robertson, Margaret, wid. Geo. 119 Hamilton av" — For twenty years, Margaret Paterson Robertson was defined by loss. The Brooklyn city directories traced her through the decades, always listed as "wid. Geo." But Margaret was more than a widow. She was the anchor of a family scattered across an ocean. Around her, the surviving children married, had children of their own, and established themselves in skilled trades. Then 1892 took everything — Margaret in July, her daughter Clementina just four months later. They lie together now at Evergreens Cemetery, in unmarked graves.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones: The Great Emigration
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Scattered Stones: The Great Emigration

Scattered Stones: Episode 3

How long resident in this City: 5 days." Those words on George Robertson's death certificate tell the story of a journey that ended almost before it began. In 1869, his son David boarded the steamship Europa for Brooklyn. In 1872, George followed — only to die of sunstroke in the brutal July heat, just five days after arriving. His widow Margaret would spend the next twenty years in Brooklyn, always identified as "wid. Geo." in the city directories. They lie together in unmarked graves at Evergreens Cemetery.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones: The Mason’s Household
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Scattered Stones: The Mason’s Household

Scattered Stones: Episode 2

In the summer of 1839, George and Margaret Robertson welcomed their first child at Couttie, near Blairgowrie. Over the next twenty-one years, they would baptize ten children in this Perthshire town — including twins named William Fraser and Clementina Stewart Ramsay, whose distinctive names hint at connections yet to be uncovered. Four Scottish censuses captured this growing family before the great emigration scattered them across two continents.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones: Roots in Perthshire
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Scattered Stones: Roots in Perthshire

Scattered Stones: Episode 1

In 1786, a weaver named Duncan Robertson married Jean Angus in Bendochy parish, Perthshire. Over the next two decades, they raised seven children in the townland of Myreridges — including a youngest son, George, born when both parents were nearly fifty. George would leave weaving behind to become a mason, marry a local woman, and eventually die just five days after arriving in America. This is where his story begins.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
Scattered Stones Prologue: The Land They Left

Scattered Stones Prologue: The Land They Left

Scattered Stones: Prologue

To understand why a family left, you must first understand what they left behind.

In the heart of Clan Robertson territory, where the Highlands meet the Lowlands, lies the parish of Bendochy—one of the oldest ecclesiastical sites in Scotland. Its parish registers begin in 1642. Two miles away, the market town of Blairgowrie sits at the edge of Strathmore valley, where rivers carve through ancient rock and the name Robertson appears in one of every twenty households.

Before we follow Duncan Robertson's descendants across the Atlantic—through Brooklyn and Georgia and New Jersey, across six generations—we must begin where they began.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
When the American Dream Reversed: The Panic of 1873

When the American Dream Reversed: The Panic of 1873

In the 1870s, thousands of Scottish immigrants made an unexpected choice: they went home. The Panic of 1873—America's first Great Depression—triggered mass unemployment while Scotland's coal and iron industries boomed. New research from the 1881 Scottish census reveals over 1,100 return migrants, including families like the Robertsons of our Scattered Stones series. This is the story of when the tide turned both ways.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Scattered Stones: The Robertson Family of Blairgowrie

Read More
Perthshire Paperweights: A Genealogists Discovery

Perthshire Paperweights: A Genealogists Discovery

A Genealogists Discovery

Genealogical research fills notebooks with names and dates, census entries and vital records. But sometimes, in the midst of all that documentation, you find something unexpected—something you can hold in your hands.

When we pinpointed Bendochy, Perthshire as the Robertson family homeland, I went searching for a tangible connection to that place. What I discovered was extraordinary: Perthshire Paperweights—intricate millefiori designs encased in crystal-clear glass, created just 25 miles from where George Robertson was born in 1809.

I purchased three: one for my mother, one for myself, and one for my daughter. Three generations of women, connected to six generations of ancestors, through a piece of Scottish glass art.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies

Read More
Hidden Bonds: The Carpenter Who Built with Double Vision

Hidden Bonds: The Carpenter Who Built with Double Vision

Miles Murtha O'Brien fell from a scaffold in an elevator shaft. The family believes it was during construction of the Chrysler Building—the timing fits, and the story has been passed down for nearly a century. He survived with only bruises—and permanent double vision. He never worked on a crew again. Instead, he spent the next fifty years as a solo carpenter, building medical offices, renovating kitchens, and raising six children with his wife Lillian. This is the story of a man who lost his mother at two, fell from a scaffold at twenty-five, and kept working until the end.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Documentary Biographies From Research to Story

Read More
Research Methodology Showcase: Solving a 1910 Family Mystery
Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales Robertson Family Stories Mary Morales

Research Methodology Showcase: Solving a 1910 Family Mystery

A Brooklyn stone mason vanished in Georgia in 1910, sparking a cross-state search by his devoted son. This cold case illustrates how modern DNA analysis, digital archives, and professional genealogy techniques could solve family mysteries that stumped investigators over a century ago.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: When professional research tackles the cold cases that have haunted families for generations.

Read More
Legacy Letter: The Orphan’s Promise

Legacy Letter: The Orphan’s Promise

A letter from Lillian Josephine Robertson O'Brien to her descendants — written in her voice, sharing what she wants them to know about surviving tragedy, building from loss, and the promise she made in January 1924 that she kept for sixty-seven years.

Part of the Storyline Genealogy series: Legacy Keepsakes From Research to Story

Read More